The Journals of Rupert Giles: Volume 1

The Journals of Rupert Giles: Volume 1

-Nancy Holder
-191 Pages
-February 2002

 

Summary: A novelization of the episodes Helpless (Season 3), A New Man (Season 4) and Blood Ties (Season 5).

   
  Rating:1/5
   
 

Review: This novel was horribly written. I think I've said it before, but I'll say it again, Nancy Holder without Chris Golden is absolute crap. She tries way too hard to be hip and all she ends up doing is using old jargon from the series in a horrible new context. Her thoughts for the characters are disjointed and obnoxious. And the amount of spelling errors I found in my novel was unbelievable. There must have been over 10 typos/poor grammar mistakes. And it wasn't from using slang either. It was just poor writing. The only reason that this novel actually stands up is because of the authors that wrote these scripts in the first place. What a disappointment. And the ending isn't even explained all that well (you know, the intros and outros they have for every novelization). So unless you're a serious BtVS collector, don't buy this book. It isn't worth the money.

   
  Click for purchasing information.